Growing communities

While some charities have made great progress, ... leaders with key questions to ask their operational teams, ... questions every board should ask...

0 downloads 94 Views 3MB Size
Growing communities #NfPSocialMedia

How charity leaders govern social media globally to thrive online

INTRODUCTION

Introduction Many charities consider social media to be an important channel to deliver on their communications and fundraising goals. Some use social media to deliver services. However, few incorporate social media as a core strategy to capitalise on its interactive opportunity to engage with new communities – at least not yet. While some charities have made great progress, there is currently a social media knowledge gap at senior levels in charities worldwide – the very people expected to govern the opportunities and risks to achieve their charity’s goals. To fill the gap Growing communities: How charity leaders govern social media globally to thrive online captures the views and experiences of charity chief executives and their peers from Australia, Botswana, Canada, Ireland, India, New Zealand, the UK and the US. Grant Thornton Not for Profit and social

media specialists asked senior executives a range of questions covering five key areas: strategy, governance, education, risk and measurement. Charity chief executives’ perspectives are combined with insights from our global Not for Profit team, to provide charity leaders with guidance on how to embrace social media and create an environment that enables their charities to thrive online. This report also equips charity leaders with key questions to ask their operational teams, to ensure resources invested in social media deliver value.

Social media is a game changer. “Charities looking to engage with a more technology literate audience need to harness the power of this rapidly evolving environment. Without an informed social media strategy – and the internal governance and operations to support it – funding may erode.



Carol Rudge | Global leader of Not for Profit | Grant Thornton @CarolRudge

linkd.in/1inDAzG

Tweet this

2 2

INTRODUCTION

Key findings Strategy: The charity’s strategy should drive social media use. The board must help formulate this strategy from a position of knowledge.

 Risk: For many charities, non-engagement is a risk in itself, although each organisation has to weigh up the cost of social media against its benefits.

 Governance: Charities should document their social media governance approach and share guidelines

 Impact: It is vital to measure impact, engagement and outcomes to justify investment in social media.

with everyone involved in their work. Clear guidance and understanding improves self-moderation.

Metrics should always be linked to a strategic goal and monitored to find the real value over time to beneficiaries.

 Education and training: Formal education programmes should be used at every level of the organisation, including volunteers when it is relevant. Internal social networks, such as Yammer and Jive, can also provide opportunities for people to gain confidence and working knowledge of social media.

3 3

Read more Strategy

05

Governance

10

Education and training 15 Risk

20

Measuring

24

Calls to action

28

Contacts

31

INTRODUCTION

questions every board should ask A 2013 Grant Thornton survey of Not for Profits in Australia and New Zealand, Doing good and doing it well found that 98% expect their social media activity to increase*. If your organisation expects greater activity, it is time to address these questions with management.

1

 hat part does social media play in our strategic W plan, who reports to the board about social media strategy and outcomes, and what is their level of experience?

2 3

Do we have guidelines to issue to staff and volunteers using social media and how do we encourage usage while mitigating risk?  ow can social networks help to aid internal H communications and break down silos across a charity? *Source: Grant Thornton survey Doing good and doing it well

4 4

4

What resources have we allocated to social

5

How can we monitor online discussions

6

Sharing the report Social media is all about sharing and collaboration. We have drawn out our key findings and best practice examples to share with you. Please add your perspective to the debate by using the Twitter hashtag #NfPSocialMedia

media projects and how do we measure our return on investment?

that our charity should be involved in? Can any of our services be delivered through social media to reach new beneficiaries?

In developing this report, we have sought knowledge from key contacts at charities who have developed strong social media strategies. Their input is highlighted with the light bulb icon throughout the report.

STRATEGY

Build in benefits from the start Social media must align with the overall strategy of the organisation. Grant Thornton has found charities are using social media to open up new funding sources, deliver innovative services and create transparency. Communication is important to charity strategy, but social media can help more broadly. There is a difference between social media being used by the majority as a low-cost marketing and communications tool, and social media being used to achieve strategic goals. It is cheap to activate, but needs investment over time to do well.

5

STRATEGY

Extending reach As well as supplementing traditional messaging channels, social media can:

1

 pen up new funding streams as traditional O donations shrink.

2

 arget beneficiaries that traditional media struggles T to reach, especially the younger generation who expect information to be delivered online.

3 Boost collaborative approaches to service delivery. 4 Act as a transparent, accountable, accessible face of the charity.

In terms of funding streams, charities are increasingly being forced by the younger demographic into event-based giving, says Deryck Williams, national leader of charities and Not for Profit, Grant Thornton Canada. “It reaches Gen X and Millennials, but the net return from these groups can be lower than from other annual givers. The benefit is that social media gives you immediate feedback and the chance to build a lasting relationship.” It is also an easy way of enabling and encouraging long-term business networking without being intrusive.

Of strategic importance The conversational aspect of social media is ideal for charities where communication is the primary objective. Two-way communication and sharing among a virtual community delivers a vital strategic goal. Scope have been proactive. They have trained a team of ‘Story Champions’ who capture the real stories of people they assist and share them with the online community. Building this two-way conversation into strategy is important. As charities experiment and research best practice for social media, they will find many opportunities to turn their activity into interactive and conversational tools of engagement. Social media amplifies the effect as champions for the charity broadcast to their wider networks, deepening current relationships and starting new ones.

6 6

With limited means of finance “and infrastructure at their disposal, many not for profit organisations, especially in Africa, must constantly reach out and broadcast their goals and needs. By adopting social media these organisations can extend their reach, especially among the younger generation who are becoming more socially conscious.



Madhavan Venkatachary | Partner | Grant Thornton Botswana linkd.in/1mdBHL8

Tweet this

STRATEGY

Changing internal cultures High-performing charities focus on their internal culture to achieve strategic change. Social media can be used

Other charities have focused on developing internal social media tools:

Grant Thornton UK launched its own internal social network, Jam, in April 2014. The platform enriches

internally as a tool that improves the organisation as well as helping beneficiaries by improving workflow, efficiency and sharing.

collaboration and sharing across the firm, supporting both business-related and social groups as part of a wider social media strategy. As eyes are opened

This can be seen clearly at charities again such

to the value of social media for business, so Jam provides a sandbox environment for people to try things

as Scope in the UK, where social media has been embraced internally: 150 digital champions have been trained across all departments, who project the personality of the charity to their digital channels. “If you’re going to have a real culture change then it has to come from the organisation doing things differently,” says Richard Hawkes, chief executive officer of Scope. “It comes back to a culture of support from the leadership team. Without that buy-in from the start it’s difficult to achieve that cultural change.”



Social media breaks down the capacity for people to be siloed. Our closed Facebook group lets 900 staff share what they’re doing and board members can congratulate people directly. It flattens the organisation beautifully. Peter Burns | Chief executive officer | YMCA Victoria, Australia @pbymca



linkd.in/1mH5UOI

Tweet this

7

like blogging and status updates in a safe environment. Leadership presence, blogs and taking the Jam experience to our annual partners’ conference blur the line between traditional communication and social channels, and open conversations to a wider audience than ever before.

STRATEGY

A social experiment Who are you hoping to speak to and where are they to be found? These questions are important when formulating strategy: they are the ‘social’ aspect. Ask yourself if your audience is open to your style of messaging on that platform. Communicating on Facebook is like inviting someone into your living room – a personal, passionate affinity. If it’s less emotional, then Twitter works better since users are open to talking outside their personal networks. LinkedIn is more like a business networking event and requires a more professional voice.

74 out of the top 100 UK charities are on all three of the main social media platforms (Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn)*.

Tweet this

What’s the most suitable social “media channel to achieve your

messaging? The demographic defines what platform is best for each stakeholder group, and each platform can have a different message.



Brent Kennerley | National leader of Not for Profit | Grant Thornton New Zealand linkd.in/1l9leqI

Tweet this

Be aware that technology may outpace the rate of change in your organisation. Setting strategy early means you will have rules to apply to unexpected situations.

You can’t anticipate “everything because social

media is dynamic and evolving. Look for the principles to guide you rather than static and inflexible processes.

Peter Derrick | Executive director | The Leprosy Mission, Canada @effecthope



linkd.in/1wBHddJ

Tweet this

*Source: Grant Thornton charity governance review 2014

8 8

STRATEGY

The best platforms for your objectives

Buy-in power

Where do our charities find their audiences?  Facebook is still most popular, but posting too frequently can be counter-productive

Shaun Robinson, chief executive officer of the New Zealand Aids Foundation, highlights three areas as key: planning; setting a strategy; and gaining board understanding and approval. Such forward planning is uncommon. A March 2014 survey of charities in the US and Canada by software company Bloomerang found that of 9,000 small to medium-sized charities, 67% had no social media strategy, policies or goals documented. Policies give staff reassurance: just knowing they exist sets an agenda for the organisation. Social media has to be linked to a broader risk management strategy from the start. The key risk factors, plans for reacting to breaches and notifying relevant team members have to be built into strategy.

Our board set a plan back in “2009 to specifically move to

social marketing in which social media is a key tool, and they are very engaged. We can easily see the benefit.



Shaun Robinson | Chief executive officer | New Zealand Aids Foundation 9 facebook.com/NZAFofficial

 Twitter is the most conversational, as it allows for fast dissemination of news and reactions  YouTube is a repository for video, which can then be embedded in communications or other social channels  Google+ is useful from a search engine optimisation (SEO) viewpoint, but is not yet exploited as a community-building tool Visual social media, such as Instagram, Snapchat and Pinterest, appears to be focused on even more specific groups such as young or female for instance. They are also ideal for creating content to share on other platforms

Tweet this

Social media can boost transparency and accountability through publishing online, offering public access to senior staff and enhancing internal communications. Objectives

Key finding

such as driving donors to income streams, encouraging successful peer-to-peer fundraising and delivering services over the internet, can all be reached more easily if there is board-level engagement.

Social media has outpaced organisational change and has huge potential to deliver services, foster internal sharing and achieve strategic goals

9

beyond communications.

GOVERNANCE

Learning to protect Many charities admit that there is a lack of understanding of social media at board level. Grant Thornton believes that understanding how to govern social media’s use, leverage its opportunities and manage its risks, is vital. Improving knowledge at senior levels is also important to understanding impact and effectiveness. Just as with any other communication channel, the board cannot become involved in every operational matter. In setting a framework for governance, they have to understand what social media is and its capabilities.

10

GOVERNANCE

Who governs? Social media is a 24-hour medium that gives the public free access to share opinions of your service, activities and brand: it can have positive and negative outcomes. A 2013 Grant Thornton study into social media use by business in the US, Social media risks and rewards found that 56% of companies do not have an incident management plan and 27% have no plans to develop a social media policy*. If these figures are reflected in the Not for Profit sector, there is cause for concern. For most charities, the communications team regulates social media activity, with assistance from information and communications technology (ICT) services. Few have specific governance guidelines or protocols in place for social media and most rely on general conduct and best practice guidelines.

Communications and marketing departments are often given delegated authority over operational social media use, sometimes without an official framework to protect themselves and the charity. Appointing a board member with interest and experience in social media, who can react quickly and communicate needs to the board, can spread understanding without involving the board in every operational problem.

Many trustees are not “digital natives and don’t

always know what they should be asking. They may struggle to establish the risks, and what they should ask management about.



Carol Rudge | Global leader of Not for Profit | Grant Thornton @CarolRudge

linkd.in/1inDAzG

Tweet this

*Source: ‘Social media risks and rewards’ by Grant Thornton US

11 11

GOVERNANCE

“I don’t think the board has to have experience in every area that brings a risk to the organisation,” says Mark Oster, managing partner Not for Profit at Grant Thornton US. “If management is doing an appropriate job, they don’t need to be skilled in social media. What the board needs, at the very least, is a basic understanding and access to advice on the subject.”



It’s about making our leaders accessible and being transparent. Nowadays, people expect to be able to ask questions and to challenge. So it’s really important for us that people have that ability. Richard Hawkes | Chief executive officer | Scope, UK 12

Of the top 100 UK charities, only 29 chief executives engaged in tweeting, with the number of followers ranging from

7 to 6,000 . *

Tweet this

*Source: Grant Thornton charity governance review 2014

12

@R_Hawkes



linkd.in/1hOkrMx

Tweet this

of social media “asThea recognition strategic tool is yet to reach the agenda of charity boards. In India it remains largely an operational tool used for fundraising and attracting volunteers by a small population of large to mid-size charities. Chief executive officers and board members need to be made aware of the benefits and associated risks of social media.



Rohit Bahadur | Partner | Grant Thornton India @GrantThorntonIN

linkd.in/1inDYhx

Tweet this

GOVERNANCE

How social media is different Although social networking isn’t a new concept, the technology enabling social media is different in terms of reach and accessibility. It is global, conversational and open. Governing its use is only possible through comprehending its differences to normal media.

When a group of people aren’t that familiar with what the medium is, “what it represents, the market they’re talking to, and what they can and can’t control, I think there is a risk around decision-making and risk management that can quickly get off balance. Any organisation that thinks it can manage the conversation that’s happening about it in the community through social media is badly mistaken. Nigel Harris | Chief executive officer | Mater Foundation, Australia @nigelsj_harris

linkd.in/1km2fV7



The 2,000-year old medium For an interesting framing of how social media fits into human history, we recommend Tom Standage’s book Social Media: The First 2,000 years. Standage eloquently argues that humans have always been social with their ideas – even Roman graffiti, wax tablets and revolutionary pamphlets count. Online and mobile technology is the way we prefer to communicate today and these are perfect platforms for social communication. Tom Standage | Digital Editor | The Economist

Tweet this @tomstandage

13

linkd.in/1oNc5oW

Tweet this

GOVERNANCE

Building frameworks Social media is an operational tool, but its enormous reach and immediacy requires appropriate governance that comes from board-level understanding. Governance in other areas is set from this level and social media should be treated in the same way. Approaching social media with preparation is essential to achieving a strong framework, giving better value for money and control over campaigns in real-time. One question we are commonly asked is: ‘Do I need two accounts, one for business and one for personal use?’ In our view the number of accounts is not important. The key is to stay authentic, open and honest in your presence on social media, whilst being aware of any boundaries set by the organisation in advance. A balance between security and personality has to be struck. Regular security checks, password changes and account reviews are all important, but charities must retain the personal touch both internally and externally. This reflects the culture of social media.

Charities need documented “user policies. Things can

become legally challenging if the personal and the organisational online presences are mixed. Compromised accounts can also sometimes be used maliciously: a particular vulnerability for charities where younger people with less experience of the need for information technology security are running social media.



Deryck Williams | National leader of charities and Not for Profit | Grant Thornton Canada @DeryckAWilliams

linkd.in/1u4XB3g

Tweet this

14 14

Key finding Charities need a certain amount of freedom when using social media to benefit from its open and rapid qualities: guidelines should be simple and easy to remember if they are to be respected. Setting formalised governance over its use, not just communications, will make social media more effective at what it does best.

EDUCATION & TRAINING

Pointing it out Social media is both immediate and interactive. It forces change and this is what differentiates it from previous methods of communication. People must learn to operate in a new environment. Charities who learn about the power that it gives relationships and credibility will gain the rewards. Education and training are largely based on operational experience: a few key team members are focused on delivering the social media output. What they learn is valuable, but every level in the organisation can benefit from a systematic approach to social media training. From volunteers to senior management, educating at every tier of the structure will mean that social media is always being used to fulfil the goals of the charity. For example, reverse mentoring programmes, such as those used at the Charity Finance Group in the UK, pair senior and junior staff together so that social media knowledge can be passed between levels. Charities that embrace social media can create an engaged, dynamic and experimental culture.

15

EDUCATION & TRAINING



Every one of our board is on social media. Every one actively engages on Facebook, Yammer and LinkedIn, and many on Twitter. I’m actively involved in each.



Peter Burns | Chief executive officer | YMCA Victoria, Australia @pbymca

linkd.in/1mH5UOI

Speak first, policy later

As well as setting guidelines for “social media use, it is important

Social media blurs the distinction between work and home. While general guidelines and training for staff cover most eventualities, social media can catch people with their guard down. The majority of our interviewees admitted that definitive policies to guide staff aren’t ready yet, and those that had such policies were still wary of the risks of self-moderation without training.

Only 53%

of US non-profits post thought leadership content on social media1

Mark Oster | National leader of Not for Profit | Grant Thornton US linkd.in/VcbKkQ

Tweet this

Tweet this

Only 1 in 10 Australian non-profits use Twitter hashtags2 Tweet this

16 16



@Mark_Oster

Tweet this

1: Source: Nonprofit Quarterly, 2014 2: Source: Wirth Consulting, 2012

for charities to communicate these policies to both their professionals and volunteers, as inappropriate individual use can reflect badly on the organisation itself.

EDUCATION & TRAINING

Mind the training gap One way that charities are protecting themselves from this training gap is by limiting use and access to social media. Many believe that by doing this they are guaranteed quality, a single brand voice and consistency with no further training. However, this is to the detriment of a social culture within the organisation. It can also create a vacuum of access, where supporters, volunteers, stakeholders – and management – deliver their own message on personal accounts, with no training. While this can be good for the charity in terms of creating a wider network aligned with the group, it has to be monitored to make sure it’s on message. Controlling the message means training and educating more staff to use social media successfully.

17 17

It benefits a charity to treat each part of their structure differently when it comes to social media training. If your staff are happy and supported, you are reducing the risk of negative actions online and they are likely to broadcast positive messages on social media about you. Fundraisers and supporters require a simple set of operational guidelines, while management should be given a more complex strategic overview. Approach the training by asking what is expected from each stakeholder to further the charity’s mission, and where they sit in the overall structure of the organisation.

We have social media “guidelines that we use for

staff and volunteers. In the guidelines that we have, even the heading says ‘Tweet, share and ping’. So we really encourage our staff and volunteers.



Ronan Ryan | Head of fundraising and communications | Irish Red Cross, Ireland @karunadaka

linkd.in/1l9lUMK

Tweet this

EDUCATION & TRAINING

Receiving support Trustees should be fully aware of their training policies. These can even be shared on social media internally, using tools such as Storify or private Facebook groups. They should recognise where resource could be well spent to achieve less risk and more return. Hiring staff with solid experience and identifying board social media champions who can educate members helps. At times, external training can be superb at sharpening a charity’s use of social media. Whether that is through a paid service, or delivered through the corporate social responsibility policy of a private company, there are resources available globally to help.



Sometimes feeding back to the board through a member who really understands the technology can be a great education that feeds into future strategy. So education can be about representation on the board as well as using outside help.



Turlough Mullen Partner and head of Not for Profit group | Grant Thornton Ireland linkd.in/1km2pvB

Tweet this

As a Not for Profit we benefit “from a lot of goodwill from

technology companies. Twitter, Facebook and Google have all invited us to participate in free seminars to tell us how to best use the product. Twitter and Google have also given the Society a batch of free advertising as part of their Not for Profit programmes, which has been invaluable.



David Drakeford | Head of information and communication technology | Irish Cancer Society, Ireland @IrishcancerSoc

linkd.in/1km2tvg

Tweet this

18

EDUCATION & TRAINING

LEGO examines its directors

Key finding

Senior management at the toy company LEGO are encouraged to sit social media exams, with theory and

Choosing and implementing the best training means that board members should understand what it is

practical tests over one day leading to a special qualification. The course culminates with a status update post on LEGO’s four million-strong Facebook page. “You

their organisation needs the most. They will only know for sure when they have been educated in social media themselves. Whether through

see the nervousness around the room when they see they need to communicate with customers,” said

corporate social responsibility outreach, nimble reverse-mentoring programmes or paid-for training

LEGO’s global director of social media Lars Silberbauer at a 2013 marketing conference. “But when they get 500 likes, that’s when they realise what social media’s all

days, they have to make time to get involved.

about.” Could charities and Not for Profits emulate this smart idea?

19 19

RISK RISK

Risks worth taking The dangers of social media are clear, but the risk to a charity of not getting involved is far greater. Our interviews revealed that isolating risks and applying appropriate resources to each should be best practice for board and senior management. Regular meetings will ensure consistency across all channels and better engagement. While including social media in the charity’s enterprise risk management from the beginning will help mitigate risks and identify opportunities. Aside from guidelines, efficient monitoring is one of the key ways charities control risk from social media. Resourcing it can be problematic. If a charity’s social media activity is the preserve of one or two people, it can reduce the charity’s ability to tackle problems head on and can affect consistency if key people leave.

20 20

They are your voice. We lost “our last Twitter operator shortly after I joined, and suddenly our tailored personality and presence was altered.



Richard Parry | Chief executive officer | Canal & River Trust, UK @CanalRiverTrust

Tweet this

RISK

An active online community steps up to rebuff

One of our sister organisations “engaged resources to respond

and send information out in accordance with monitored conversations. People said they felt like there was a helpful expert walking alongside their conversation. For example, someone posted a comment wondering if obesity affects MS. The experts in the background curated and sent out a summary of obesity findings the next day.



Lincoln Hopper | Chief executive officer | MS Society Queensland, Australia @msqld

linkd.in/UtfWwv

Tweet this

critics, but the primary information has to come from the charity and its experts. Using specialist tools that report on keywords and sentiment in social media gives charities the opportunity to step in if negative or false reports are circulating, and to feed into beneficial conversations at the right time. As with many tools, cost may impact accuracy, a challenge charities should be aware of. Social media can also be a proactive tool to counter risks. RSPCA Queensland in Australia, for instance, used a Facebook posting to temporarily rehome 350 animals at risk from flooding in just a few hours. The Irish Cancer Society used social media to keep donors informed when their website systems crashed late one Friday night after a friend of the charity made an unplanned appeal on a late-night chat show. Charities risk missing these opportunities if they do not engage. Giving staff training to identify risks and the means to report and counter them is a good start. Making sure senior levels understand the technological as well as reputational risks of social media is essential. Since the technology may be out of their control, the speed and effectiveness of their response is all the more important.

21 21

There are two main risks to be “managed: technology and

reputation. Charities have a fair understanding of reputational risk, but aren’t so good at profiling technological risk.



Deryck Williams | National leader of charities and Not for Profit | Grant Thornton Canada @DeryckAWilliams

linkd.in/1u4XB3g

Tweet this

RISK

Look who’s talking

Anything to report?

Avoiding risk means asking who has access, when

Reporting on social media should be part of the larger enterprise risk management reporting structure, but

they should join the conversation and how they should speak. Some companies insist on mandatory social media training for all staff online to avoid reputational risk through unqualified commentary, careless remarks or simply contradictory, repetitive conversations. Guidelines can also be issued at a volunteer level to minimise exposure to risk, though this is only advised if your volunteers are experienced and can be relied on to manage your reputation online.

ad-hoc reporting to the board in extreme cases seems to be the general rule, with few charities having social media-specific lines of reporting. Many interviewees said that a formal approach to risk might not work. Social media is relaxed, fast and informal. If staff have robust guidelines and training, they can be left to selfmoderate. As Caron Bradshaw, chief executive officer of Charity Finance Group UK points out, the biggest risk is wasting time. Simplicity is the key to setting successful protocols. “Don’t create obstacles that cause an overly cautious approach,” says Paul Thomas, senior manager digital communications and social media, Grant Thornton UK. “We don’t read policy unless we think we may have broken it, so keep guidelines simple, open and accessible, much like the medium itself.”

22 22

Do you stand next to your “staff at a networking event

and police everything that they say? Our approach to risk is about trying to get staff to think about the consequences of their actions and mitigating the consequences of the actions of others.



Caron Bradshaw | Chief executive officer | Charity Finance Group, UK @caronlb

linkd.in/1lmZjw1

Tweet this

RISK

Who knows the rules? “Few Not for Profits have spoken to us about social media, which suggests there isn’t much focus on strategy,” says Jan Hertzberg, managing director business advisory services, Grant Thornton US. “The greatest risk is disclosure: safeguarding information is essential, and you need strategic limitation of what you can and can’t do. Training and awareness are critical in formulating this policy.”

Selfies & identity crisis The #nomakeupselfie viral campaign raised over £8m for Cancer Research UK in 2014, translating well to text-based phone communications thanks to its donor text code. There were a few cases where predictive text, or a wrong number, resulted in UNICEF or the WWF receiving donations in error. The two charities were quick to correct the problem, but the ease of virality slipping into risk exposure is clear.

23 23

Key finding Risks will always be present on social media but they are outweighed by the opportunities it offers. Engaging with social media at board and senior management level will help to avoid mistakes and minimise the risks that are everpresent. Understanding the risks strategically rather than expecting operational involvement from the board is the best way forward.

MEASURING

Reaching for more tools Measurements give the board an indication of benefits: investment in social media should be based upon proof of how effective it is at achieving a charity’s goals. Income is only one such indicator. For some charities, communication is a simple thing to measure on social media. Downloads, unique views and shares can all be viewed as indicators, which combine with anecdotal evidence to give a snapshot of effectiveness. Measurement techniques should enable easy comparison to other means of delivery. If the planning and targets are not in place and linked to strategic organisational goals, then there is not much point using the tools. In the words of the Irish Cancer Society, “If you have analytics but no events and goals, you just have a fancy hit counter. It’s not about how many visitors, it’s about what they do.” Enthusiasm for analytic tools can also be tempered by cost: not every charity has the budget to employ them.

24

MEASURING

When tools are not required By tracking and analysing referrals, views and usage over time, the success of campaigns can be inferred from the data. The principle is to link back to strategy: have the right people been targeted, what proportion can be expected to respond and what is the long-term result? Investment in resources, training and creating social media guidelines will be easier if management have a firm and fixed notion of value. Analytics are the way to achieve that.

There is no point investing in “social media unless it is successful in meeting the organisation’s strategic objectives. Knowing how you will define success will help you set your goals in the planning stage – what are you trying to achieve by using social media and how will you know when you’ve been successful? Measurement is crucial to understanding whether those goals have been achieved.



Simon Hancox | National leader of not for profit | Grant Thornton Australia @GrantThorntonAU

linkd.in/1qtipBp

Tweet this

25 25

delivering the results “toIt’stheabout board and proving what

you did. If we can show how social media impacts, with specific, positive data then you generate greater buy-in.



Caron Bradshaw | Chief executive officer | Charity Finance Group, UK @caronlb

linkd.in/1lmZjw1

Tweet this

MEASURING

We’re really excited by a tool “called SumAll, which allows

you to pull analytics from Google, Facebook, Twitter, your shop and your blog and collect them all into a timeline that you can make notes on. You can see spikes where blog posts have triggered interest and responses.



Peter Derrick | Chief executive director | The Leprosy Mission, Canada @effecthope

linkd.in/1l89EaJ

Tweet this

The sharpest tools Some charities are already ahead of the pack in terms of introducing third-party analytics tools to measure effectiveness. These tools allow them to understand movements online and how they affect their strategy, by simplifying the data and collating it to allow for easier comparison and reporting. Social media monitoring company Brandwatch, for instance, even offer preferential rates to not for profits. Several of our interviewees have experienced the value of these tools. One charity, tracking the referrals from a YouTube advert they had filmed, found 30,000 views led to only one donation. Another analysed data to find that asking people to fundraise for them over Facebook had twice the return on investment as asking directly for donations on the same platform. These tools are evolving fast: new sentiment analysis programmes such as ForSight track feelings in language, giving an insight into emotional engagement and attitudes.

26 26

We’ve imported Facebook “Insights and Google Analytics

into Sprout Social, a social media tool that puts everything on one screen. We’re able to see all the Facebook Insights into engagement clicks and various reach data, without logging into Facebook at all. It gives quite accurate Twitter metrics as well.



David Drakeford | Head of information and communication technology | Irish Cancer Society, Ireland @IrishCancerSoc

linkd.in/1km2tvg

Tweet this

MEASURING

Measurement tools

USAID does it with feeling

“Three effective tools are Sysomos (sysomos.com), Market Wired (marketwired.com) and Radian6

USAID has completed a pilot study in Kenya using the ForSight programme to follow the sentiments expressed on social media. By observing and

(salesforcemarketingcloud.com), but none of them will do you good unless you know what you are measuring towards,” says Lucino Sotelo, head of digital marketing at Grant Thornton US. “While social media has been a godsend for Not for Profits in the US, activity is rarely led from the grass roots. Recently, San Franciscans mobilised on social media to transform their city into Gotham city for a five‑year‑old boy who wanted to be Batman and had been in touch with Make‑A‑Wish They generated a lot of funds, but none of it was accidental: there was a social media strategist. Charities may have more luck winning the lottery than relying on fate to let their campaign go viral. You have to build a strategy first, build in measurement from the start, and use it to further your goals.”

27 27

collating language cues, their programme was able to understand how people felt about an issue – in this case, loan finance. Using tools in this way allows Not for Profits and charities a way to use the data generated automatically by beneficiaries.

Key finding Many tools are available to help with the job of measurement. But measuring is only useful if it tracks a strategic goal. Before allocating budget the board should be happy they are helping to move the charity’s objectives forward.

CALLS TO ACTION

Calls to action Our insights to help you get the most from social media

Our report reveals many parallels across the world in how social media is being applied. Social media is a global tool, open to all: best practice can also be adopted globally. No matter what your charity does or where it operates, there are key lessons you can learn to use social media better.

28

CALLS TO ACTION

1 Strategy • Look beyond communication strategy. Make social 

•  Education and training programmes should include

media part of the wider business strategy to engage with all your audiences and drive new donors

setting guidelines for those taking part, as well as protocols for individual and corporate use. They

to your website

should be tailored to the appropriate levels to ensure each group understands their role

attending workshops and training to gain • Consider  a level of understanding that allows you and your board to formulate an effective strategy • Social media changes quickly, and charities have  to stay current in their approach either through hiring skilled employees, training internally or using third party resources

2 Governance • Guidance is needed at every level of the  organisation, from board to operational staff and volunteers where appropriate. • Keeping  guidance simple will make it more likely to be followed. See examples at: http://socialmediagovernance.com/ policies/#tabs-61-tab-6  • Monitoring conversations on social media is how your charity can gain insights into how it is perceived and may lead to new opportunities

29

3 Education and training

•  Consider using internal social networks to boost understanding and confidence in social media tools and improve collaboration in charities that are spread over many locations or branches •  Formalise the training given to the networks of volunteers and supporters around the charity’s use of social media and best practice

4 Managing risk •  For many charities, non-engagement is a risk in itself, although each charity has to weigh up the costs against social media’s benefits •  Drawing up clear and consistent guidelines for use is necessary. Monitoring every interaction is not possible or desirable, so self-moderation and judgement is key

5 Measuring impact •  The metrics your charity uses should always link to a strategic goal. Understanding the impact of social media over time, and its varying platforms and specialities, allows your charity to refine strategy as you operate •  Knowing the numbers is important, especially when making decisions about resources and budgets •  Measure engagement, not just followers. Stories and conversations are the lifeblood of social media, so pursue them alongside the hard figures

CALLS TO ACTION

Further reading to stay ahead Grant Thornton would like to thank the following charities who were interviewed for this report, some of which are quoted. You can keep up to date with their work via Twitter with the handles below.

Further reading There is a wealth of not for profit social media reports and blogs online. Here are our top 6 suggestions for further reading: Aegis Media and Social Misfits Media’s guide: ‘Something to tweet about’ explores

Thank you to the following charities

how to make the most of content in the social media world.

Charity

Twitter handle

Charity

Twitter handle

Alzheimer’s Association

@alzassociation

Multiple Sclerosis Queensland

@msqld

Arthritis New Zealand

@ArthritisNZ

New Zealand Aids Foundation

@NZAFofficial

Barnardos New Zealand

@BarnardosNZ

RSPCA Queensland

@RSPCA_official

Euan Semple: Organizations Don’t Tweet, People Do: A Manager’s Guide to the Social

Canal & River Trust

@CanalRiverTrust

Scope

@scope

Web provides a manager’s guide to the social web.

Charity Finance Group (CFG)

@CFGtweets

The Mater Foundation

@MaterNews

Irish Cancer Society

@IrishCancerSoc

Unicef

@unicef

Zoe Amar & Matt Collins: How to – social media for charity leaders demystifies social

Irish Red Cross

@IrishRedCross

Year Up

@yearup

effect:hope

@effecthope

YMCA Victoria

@ymcavictoria

YMCA Edmonton

@YMCANorthernAB

The Leprosy Mission Canada

Tom Standage: Social Media: The First 2000 years gives practical advice and examples of how to make social media work in your organisation.

media and offers straightforward strategies for charity leaders. Jennifer Begg: live free range blog provides insight from this consultant who works with organisations to deliver comprehensive social media training. Top 150 non-profit blogs in the world

30

CONTACTS

Global contacts GLOBAL LEADER Carol Rudge

United Kingdom

+44 (0) 20 7728 2400

[email protected]

Grant Thornton is able to advise you in key areas addressed in this report. We understand the importance of social media to wider governance

Simon Hancox

Australia

+61 (7) 3222 0200

[email protected]

Rohit Bahadur

India

+91 11 4278 7010

[email protected]

issues and can provide you with an international perspective to best practice. Social media is here

Vinh Ha Nguyen

Vietnam

+84 9 0412 8675

[email protected]

Brent Kennerley

New Zealand

+64 (0) 4 495 3771

[email protected]

ASIA PACIFIC

to stay, but it is evolving fast. There is no right way for everyone – just the right way for your charity. Finding that way is where we can help.

AFRICA Madhavan Venkatachary

Botswana

+267 395 2313

[email protected]

Moustapha Coulibaly

Ivory Coast

+22 522 426650

[email protected]

Mansour Gaye

Senegal

+221 33 889 70 70

[email protected]

Barry Lodewyk

South Africa

+27 2141 78800

[email protected]

Constant Awesso

Togo

+228 22 25 87 74

[email protected]

Rodia Musonda

Zambia

+26 0211 227 722

[email protected]

Alice Mafanuke

Zimbabwe

+263 4 442511

[email protected]

Deryck Williams

Canada

+1 416 360 4954

[email protected]

Christine Regimbal

Canada (Quebec)

+1 514 878 2691

[email protected]

Mark Oster

United States

+1 212 542 9770

[email protected]

Turlough Mullen

Ireland

+353 (0) 1 6805608

[email protected]

Roberta Papa

Italy

+39 027 600 8751

[email protected]

Pernilla Varverud

Sweden

+46 8 5630 7125

[email protected]

Carol Rudge

United Kingdom

+44 (0) 20 7728 2400

[email protected]

AMERICAS

EUROPE

31

To find out more visit:

www.gti.org

About us Grant Thornton is one of the world’s leading organisations of independent assurance, tax and advisory firms. These firms help dynamic organisations unlock their potential for growth by providing meaningful, forward looking advice. Proactive teams, led by approachable partners in these firms, use insights, experience and instinct to understand complex issues for privately owned, publicly listed and public sector clients and help them to find solutions. More than 38,500 Grant Thornton people, in over 130 countries, are focused on making a difference to clients, colleagues and the communities in which we live and work.

© 2014 Grant Thornton International Ltd. All rights reserved “Grant Thornton” refers to the brand under which the Grant Thornton member firms provide assurance, tax and advisory services to their clients and/or refers to one or more member firms, as the context requires. Grant Thornton International Ltd (GTIL) and the member firms are not a worldwide partnership. GTIL and each member firm is a separate legal entity. Services are delivered by the member firms. GTIL does not provide services to clients. GTIL and its member firms are not agents of, and do not obligate, one another and are not liable for one another’s acts or omissions. www.gti.org